|
From the Chair

The Board joins the bench and bar of this Commonwealth in mourning former Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille, who passed away on November 4, 2026, at the age of 82. His was a life defined by service — to his country as an officer in the United States Marine Corps, to his city as District Attorney of Philadelphia, and to this Commonwealth as a Justice and, ultimately, the 55th Chief Justice of its Supreme Court. Over two decades on the Court, he authored more than 400 majority opinions expounding upon virtually every area of the law and the thoughtful analysis characteristic of the Chief Justice Castille’s responsive opinions will continue to shape Pennsylvania’s jurisprudence for decades to come. Put simply, the judicial legacy he leaves is remarkable by any measure.
But even a legacy of such magnitude as Chief Justice Castille’s cannot sustain itself; rather, it endures in the hands of the next generation of lawyers. And what is true of a Chief Justice is true, in more modest measure, of every member of the bar. The work we leave behind, and the clients who relied upon it, pass ultimately into the care of those who follow us. It is in that light that the Board’s most recent look at the profession merits attention.
In October, the Board released the aggregate results of the demographic and succession planning data collected during the 2026-2027 Annual Attorney Registration. The portrait that emerges is an instructive one. More than half of Pennsylvania attorneys are fifty or older. Solo practitioners, meanwhile, are nearly as numerous as attorneys practicing in large firms (i.e., those with more than fifty lawyers).
Of particular note, more than 14% of the attorneys who reported representing private clients in the past year have not designated a successor, whether an individual or a law firm. While succession planning is not mandatory in Pennsylvania, the Board nevertheless regards it as essential to the ethical practice of law and strongly encourages every attorney to prepare for the unforeseen, for the sake of the clients and colleagues who will carry the work forward. For those wondering where to begin, former Board Chair Dion G. Rassias—with whom I had the pleasure of serving for several years—penned an excellent article on the subject in 2019, which I commend to all readers.
Finally, as the holiday season approaches, the legal profession of this Commonwealth has much for which to be grateful. On behalf of the Board, I wish you and your loved ones a joyful and restful Thanksgiving.
Shohin H. Vance
Board Chair
|
|
|
Remembering Former Chief Justice
Ronald D. Castille

Supreme Court Mourns Passing of Former Chief Justice Ronald Castille
On November 5, 2026, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania announced the passing of former Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille.
Chief Justice Debra Todd stated, “I am deeply saddened by the passing of former Chief Justice Ron Castille, whose life was defined by an extraordinary commitment to service, duty and the pursuit of justice. His contributions to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and to the citizens of this Commonwealth leave a lasting mark on our Commonwealth.”
Chief Justice Castille was District Attorney of Philadelphia from 1986 until 1991. In 1993 he was elected a Justice of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, on which he served from 1994 until his retirement in 2014. He became the 55th Chief Justice in Pennsylvania history on January 14, 2008, and remained in that role for the remainder of his time in office.
The Court noted that Justice Castille authored more than four hundred majority opinions touching upon virtually every area of law. These included seminal opinions in the areas of court funding, judicial independence, torts, criminal law, education, labor relations, zoning, taxation, workers compensation, insurance, oil and gas, judicial conduct, and attorney discipline. He contributed greatly to the law of the Pennsylvania Constitution, authoring opinions in important cases involving freedom of expression, the Environmental Rights Amendment, reapportionment and redistricting, criminal procedure, excessive fines, and the separation of powers.
He also led the courts through difficult economic times, ensuring that no court in Pennsylvania closed for a single day during periods of budgetary shortfalls. He also worked to reduce civil case backlogs; promoted juvenile justice reform; spearheaded implementation of stronger judicial conduct codes; implemented measures to fast-track family law matters; and led many initiatives to improve the First Judicial District in Philadelphia. He also sought to improve access to justice, supporting civil legal aid programs for the indigent and pro bono legal assistance, and oversaw the creation of the Elder Law Task Force to focus on legal issues affecting older Pennsylvanians.
Chief Justice Todd concluded, “On behalf of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, I extend my heartfelt condolences to Chief Justice Castille’s wife, Susan Kilgus Castille, and to his family, friends and all who had the privilege of serving alongside him. We honor his legacy of service to our country and our Commonwealth, and we remain grateful for his many contributions to the Pennsylvania judiciary.”
|
|
|
|
Discipline Imposed
October 2026
|
|
|
|
Reinstatements
October 2026
Note: The above-listed granted reinstatement matters reflect only those granted by Supreme Court Order. An attorney listed as reinstatement granted, but whose current license status does not reflect reinstatement, has yet to submit the fees necessary to finalize reinstatement.
|
|
|
|
Disciplinary Board News
Considering Retirement?
Retirement tends to be a common end-of-year event. If you are considering an end to your law practice in Pennsylvania, what should you do about your license? One thing is for sure -- do not do nothing.
Your retirement from the practice of law only affects your license status if you effect a change. If you simply choose to not complete your annual registration or your CLE requirement, you will receive late penalties and ultimately be administratively suspended. Instead, pursue one of the following options:
- Continue maintaining active status. If you would like to maintain your ability to practice law, you should complete all requirements of an actively-licensed attorney (annual registration, CLE, etc.).
- Assume inactive status. While inactive status still requires annual registration, assuming such status automatically defers your CLE requirement. If you are unsure of your need to practice law in the future, consider maintaining inactive status. Please see the Board’s "Reinstatement" page for information about reinstatement from inactive status.
- Assume retired status. If you believe that your need to practice law in Pennsylvania has concluded, assuming retired status will end your annual requirements (annual registration, CLE, etc.). Please see the Board’s "Reinstatement" page for information about reinstatement from retired status.
- Assume emeritus status. After assuming retired status, an attorney may request to assume emeritus status. Emeritus status allows a retired attorney to provide pro bono services to eligible Legal Aid Organizations. For more information, please see the FAQs regarding emeritus status and the Board’s "Pro Bono" page.
Visit the Board’s "Forms" page to find appropriate forms to request the above status changes and, as always, make sure that your contact information is always up to date.
|
|
|
Upcoming Public Proceedings
We encourage you to observe our public disciplinary and reinstatement hearings, oral arguments, and public reprimands on the Board’s YouTube channel. You can also view “Upcoming Public Proceedings” at the bottom of the Board’s home page.
Scheduled proceedings begin at 9:30 am unless otherwise noted.

|
|
|
|
Articles of Interest
Former Magisterial District Judge Reprimanded for Misrepresenting Residence
The Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania ordered that a Monroe County lawyer who formerly served as a Magisterial District Judge be publicly reprimanded. By Joint Petition for Discipline on Consent, he admitted that he claimed he was a resident of his magisterial district when he was not.
In July 2022, John Robert Caffese sought nomination to serve as a Magisterial District Judge in Tobyhanna and Tunkhannock Townships, Monroe County. At the time he resided in the city of Stroudsburg, which was not within the judicial district in which he sought nomination. Residency in the district for one year is required for appointment or election to the office. In December 2021, Caffese rented a room in Pocono Summit, which is within the district. In his questionnaire, he listed the Pocono Summit address as his residence, and the Stroudsburg address as his business address. He also registered to vote using the Pocono Summit address, but listed the Stroudsburg site as his mailing address. He subsequently filled out several more forms, including a Statement of Financial Interests and a Senate Nomination Questionaire, stating that the Pocono Summit rental was his residential address. He was nominated by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate to the Magisterial District Justice position.
Four months later, after the nature of his residential situation was discovered, he was charged with 13 counts of various offenses, including receiving stolen property, theft by deception, false swearing, and false statement under penalty of perjury. By Order dated December 14, 2022, the Court of Judicial Discipline placed him on suspension without pay pending resolution of the criminal charges. He later pled nolo contendere to one count of obstructing the administration of law, a misdemeanor of the second degree. He was sentenced to six months of probation and payment of costs. He failed to report the conviction to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel, although he had already received and responded to a DB-7 Letter of Inquiry.
The Joint Petition sets forth Caffese’s belief in good faith that his rental of the Pocono Summit room was sufficient to establish residency, and that he did not intend to deceive anyone.
The parties agreed that Caffese’s conviction established cause for discipline under Rule 8.4(d) of the Rules of Professional Conduct, commission of a criminal act reflecting adversely on honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness to practice, and Rule 203(b)(1) of the Rules of Disciplinary Enforcement, conviction of a crime as a basis for discipline.
After review of six mitigating factors and the caselaw of comparable cases, the parties agreed that Public Reprimand was the appropriate level of discipline. A three-member panel of the Disciplinary Board recommended this disposition, and the Disciplinary Board ordered the public reprimand on September 28, 2026.
Advisory Committee on Artificial Intelligence Proposes Notice
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Advisory Committee on Artificial Intelligence has published a proposed notice regarding the use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) resources in court filings. The proposed notice is published at 56 Pa.B. 6888 (October 24, 2026).
The proposed notice states that filers who use GenAI remain fully responsible for the accuracy and integrity of the documents they file with a court. Filers must confirm that: (1) all legal authorities intended for the court to consider actually exist; (2) all quoted material appears in the legal source identified; (3) any summary of legal principles is reasonably supported by the actual text of the legal source identified; and (4) all stated facts have a basis in the record of the case.
A certification in the following form must be attached to all documents filed: ''I certify that this filing complies with the provisions of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Notice Regarding the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence by All Court Filers that requires me to review and confirm the accuracy of any language in this filing that was drafted by or with the assistance of generative artificial intelligence, including but not limited to citations, paraphrased assertions, quotations, facts and statements, and legal analysis.''
Consequences for failure to comply with the standards set forth in the notice could include:
• Reprimand by the court;
• The court not considering the filing;
• Dismissal of the case;
• Payment of costs and attorneys' fees; and/or
• Order to correct the filing.
The Committee will consider any comments received by November 24, 2026.
AI Roundup: Judges, Lawyers Caught, Maybe/Maybe Not for AI-Created Evidence
Speaking of Artificial Intelligence, stories about the complications of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) continue to proliferate.
We have shared many stories about lawyers caught up in citing nonexistent cases and authorities because they did not take the time to personally check drafts developed through GenAI. Judges get caught up in that trap, as well.
A three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at New Orleans reversed the decision of a Mississippi District Court judge and lifted a preliminary injunction entered by the judge, based on a finding that the judge’s orders contained false citations which he admitted were generated by a law clerk using Perplexity, a GenAI legal tool. The decision noted that the judge got both facts and law wrong, including mention of plaintiffs and defendants who were not in the complaint, “declarations” from people who did not exist or were never present, and false quotations that were supposedly taken from the text of the law. Worse yet, he withdrew the temporary restraining order (TRO) without explanation and substituted another, which also contained hallucinated material. He then incorporated the second TRO, uncorrected, into the Preliminary Injunction order. The Court of Appeals reversed the grant of the preliminary injunction on substantive grounds and remanded the matter with directions to assign it to a different judge. The Court commented, “[T]he public esteem for the judiciary would be diminished by sending this case back to the same judge for judgment on facts and law entirely different from those upon which he supported his initial TRO.” It added, “We are confident that an objective observer might question the impartiality of the proceedings, for the reasons stated above, and therefore might further question later proceedings run by the same judge.”
An article in the ABA Journal notes that courts are increasingly critical of lawyers who fail to detect and call attention to hallucinated and inaccurate information in opponents’ filings. In September 2025, the California Court of Appeal imposed a $10,000 sanction on plaintiff’s counsel for filing briefs with fabricated citations and quotations, but it also declined to award attorney fees to the respondent’s counsel, because counsel did not alert the court to the fabricated citations and appear to have become aware of the issue only when the court issued its order to show cause. In another case, the same court held that a party had forfeited his right to appeal a lower court decision relying on false authorities, because counsel had not only failed to object to or notify the trial court of the fabricated citations but had drafted and submitted a proposed order containing them. The article cites four other cases where courts criticized counsel for failing to discover and advise the court of false authorities citied by opponents. April Dawson, the faculty director of the Howard Law Artificial Intelligence Initiative, who has been tracking such cases, commented that due diligence and competence require lawyers to zealously advocate for their clients, which includes carefully reading cases their opponents rely on in arguments.
Courts are being called on to assess the reliability and admissibility of AI-generated evidence.
The Arizona Court of Appeals vacated a judgment of sentence that was based in part on a video depicting an AI image of a road rage shooting victim, sandwiched around an actual video of him speaking. The AI video added substance to what the victim said and specifically addressed his reactions to the shooting and comments addressed to the defendant. This content was based on what the victim’s sister speculated he would probably say. While noting that Arizona gives wide latitude for victim impact evidence, the court held that the video crossed the line by presenting statements as coming directly from the victim, including non-verbal communications made through facial expressions and the like. The Court commented, “it erases the interpretive distance between the family’s belief about what the victim would have said and the victim’s own voice and opinions.” Indeed, the video presented the AI victim as saying, “this here is a true representation of who I was, you know, not how the courtroom portrayed me.” The Court concluded, “No disclaimer could cure that error.”
But in Texas, the state Supreme Court is considering whether to allow AI-generated transcripts for witness depositions where verified video recordings can act as a backup to ensure accuracy. At oral arguments, some of the Justices seemed open to the practice, while others expressed security concerns. One Justice commented, “We have all of these escape hatches. We have the actual recording. We have the ability of the judge to say ‘Okay, there’s just too much about this. I want a certified shorthand reporter to do this.’ We have lots of techniques, if accuracy is really what the goal is.”
Judge Censured Following 'Little Experiment' In Court with Gun, Stapler
New York’s Commission on Judicial Conduct censured a judge in the New York City Criminal Court for an “experiment” he performed in court, which involved a gun, a stapler, and a bit of lying.
Judge Jeffrey A. Gershuny thought he’d try an experiment to trick a police officer testifying in a suppression hearing focused on a police search that resulted in a recovered handgun. He told the officer that he was placing his personal handgun in a bag, and giving it to the officer to explain to the court how he could tell that it was a firearm. However, he placed his own gun on the floor and put a stapler in the bag. He asked a number of questions that repeated that the gun was in the bag. After examining the bag, the officer testified that he could tell it contained “an L-shaped object,” which might be a firearm, but he would have to do a frisk to confirm that. The judge then revealed that it was in fact a stapler. During a recess, his court officer told him that she was uncomfortable with the idea of his experiment, and called her supervisor, who came to court and told the judge that he shouldn’t do it. Nonetheless, the judge suppressed the gun as evidence, saying his experiment was one of many things influencing his decision.
In its determination, the Judicial Commission noted, “It is fundamental that deception is antithetical to the role of a Judge who is sworn to uphold the law and seek the truth,” and found that Judge Gershuny “exercised poor judgment when he engaged in deceptive conduct,” and noted that his actions were “inappropriate for a judge who is ‘sworn to uphold the truth-seeking process.'” It noted mitigating factors that he did not derive any personal benefit from his conduct, his misconduct involved a single incident, and he disclosed his misrepresentations during the proceeding in which he made them.
The Commission accepted a stipulation by the parties and imposed censure on Judge Gershuny as agreed in the stipulation.
|
|
|
Attorney Well-Being
Explore the Disciplinary Board's Lawyer Well-Being Webpage
The Disciplinary Board's "Lawyer Well-Being" webpage connects Pennsylvania attorneys with pertinent resources, articles, events, and CLE opportunities to better understand and support their mental health and well-being. To access the Board’s “Lawyer Well-Being” page, visit padisciplinaryboard.org/for-attorneys/well-being.


Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers is a confidential assistance program for the Pennsylvania legal community and their family members. LCL may not report information about a subject attorney back to the Disciplinary Board.
Confidential 24/7 Helpline: 1-888-999-1941
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania adopted amendments to the Pennsylvania Rules of Disciplinary Enforcement (Pa.R.D.E.) relating to confidentiality of proceedings, providing for three exceptions to the requirement of confidentiality under Pa.R.D.E. 402(d). Included in these exceptions is the allowance for Disciplinary Counsel to make a referral of an attorney to Lawyers Concerned for Lawyers of Pennsylvania (LCL) and share information as part of the referral. However, it is crucial to note that LCL may not report information about a subject attorney back to the Disciplinary Board. LCL is a confidential assistance program for the Pennsylvania legal community and their family members.
|
|
|
Around the Court

Chief Justice of Pennsylvania Announces Passing of Former Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania is mourning the loss of former Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille, who died on November 4, 2026. He was 82 years old.
Chief Justice Debra Todd offered the following statement:
“I am deeply saddened by the passing of former Chief Justice Ron Castille, whose life was defined by an extraordinary commitment to service, duty and the pursuit of justice. His contributions to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and to the citizens of this Commonwealth leave a lasting mark on our Commonwealth.
Chief Justice Castille’s life was defined by service. Upon graduating from Auburn University in 1966 with a Bachelor of Science degree in economics, he was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the United States Marine Corps. He served as a rifle platoon commander with Company F, 2nd Battalion, 7th Marines, 1st Marine Division in Vietnam. On March 16, 1967—his 23rd birthday—while leading a search-and-destroy mission near Đức Phổ in Quảng Ngãi Province, his unit came under attack by a Viet Cong battalion. Lieutenant Castille was severely wounded by enemy gunfire. He was rescued by his platoon Sergeant, Angel Mendez, who himself was mortally wounded in the rescue.
Ron Castille lost his right leg as a result of his injuries and was medically retired from the Marine Corps in 1968. For his valor he received the Bronze Star Medal with Combat “V,” two Purple Hearts, and other distinctions. Thereafter, he walked with crutches for the remainder of his life, yet he remained an avid golfer, downhill skier and boater.
He often remarked that he lived his life in honor of Angel Mendez and others with whom he served who made the ultimate sacrifice.
Following a lengthy period of convalescence at the Philadelphia Naval Hospital, he earned his Juris Doctor degree from the University of Virginia School of Law in 1971. That same year he joined the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office under District Attorney Arlen Specter. Over the next fourteen years he served as an assistant and then deputy district attorney, rising to leadership roles that included chief of the Career Criminal Unit. He tried numerous cases and developed a reputation as a skilled and determined prosecutor.
In 1985 he was elected District Attorney of Philadelphia. He served from 1986 until 1991, twice elected by the voters. As District Attorney he oversaw an office of more than 200 attorneys handling tens of thousands of criminal cases annually. He emphasized vigorous prosecution of violent crime, led major investigations involving organized crime, drug trafficking, and public corruption, and worked to improve the efficiency of the city’s criminal justice system. While District Attorney, he spearheaded the development of the Philadelphia Vietnam Veterans Memorial. He left the office in 1991 and entered private practice with the firm of Reed Smith Shaw & McClay after an unsuccessful run for Mayor of Philadelphia.
In 1993 he was elected a Justice of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. He took office in January 1994 and was retained by the voters in 2003 and 2013. On January 14, 2008, he was sworn in as Chief Justice of Pennsylvania, the 55th Chief Justice in Pennsylvania history, serving in that capacity until his mandatory retirement at age 70 on December 31, 2014.
Chief Justice Castille left a substantial judicial legacy, authoring more than four hundred majority opinions touching upon virtually every area of law. He authored seminal opinions in the areas of court funding, judicial independence, torts, criminal law, education, labor relations, zoning, taxation, workers compensation, insurance, oil and gas, judicial conduct, and attorney discipline. He was particularly influential in developing law under the Pennsylvania Constitution, authoring important cases involving freedom of expression, the Environmental Rights Amendment, reapportionment and redistricting, criminal procedure, excessive fines, and the separation of powers.
On the administrative side, Chief Justice Castille shepherded the courts through difficult economic times, ensuring that no court in Pennsylvania closed for a single day during periods of budgetary shortfalls. He prioritized the reduction of civil case backlogs; led efforts toward juvenile justice reform; spearheaded implementation of stronger judicial conduct codes; implemented measures to fast-track family law matters; and led many initiatives to improve the First Judicial District in Philadelphia. He also was an unwavering advocate for access to justice, supporting civil legal aid programs for the indigent and pro bono legal assistance.
In light of the special needs of our elder Pennsylvanians, in 2013 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, at the direction of Chief Justice Castille, established the Elder Law Task Force to focus on legal issues affecting older Pennsylvanians. He noted at that time: “The needs of this growing population will continue for years to come, especially in regard to guardianship, elder abuse and access to justice. Now is the time to put into place solutions that will allow older Pennsylvanians to age without worries that they will be abused or that their money will be taken.” The Office of Elder Justice in the Courts and Advisory Council on Elder Justice, established in 2015, are part of Ron Castille’s legacy of service to Pennsylvania.
“On behalf of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, I extend my heartfelt condolences to Chief Justice Castille’s wife, Susan Kilgus Castille, and to his family, friends and all who had the privilege of serving alongside him. We honor his legacy of service to our country and our Commonwealth, and we remain grateful for his many contributions to the Pennsylvania judiciary.”
|
|
|
From the Pennsylvania Bar Association

From the Pennsylvania Bar Association: Turn Up the Music at NightOUT 2026!
Good music, great company and a great cause! Join the Pennsylvania Bar Foundation for NightOUT 2026 on Thursday, Nov. 12, from 6 to 9 p.m. at the Hilton Harrisburg.
Following the PBA’s Committee/Section Day, trade the meeting room for an evening of laughter, connection and entertainment featuring Felix and Fingers Dueling Pianos! This high-energy, interactive show puts the audience in charge of the playlist. Request your favorite songs, sing along and enjoy a fun-filled evening with friends and colleagues from across Pennsylvania's legal community.
But NightOUT is about more than entertainment. Proceeds support the Pennsylvania Bar Foundation and its mission to advance access to justice, strengthen legal services and make a meaningful difference in communities throughout the commonwealth.
Bring a colleague, invite a friend, or make it a night out with someone special. Everyone is welcome!
Event Details:
- Thursday, Nov. 12 | 6–9 p.m.
- Hilton Harrisburg | Harrisburg, Pa.
Dinner tickets are $120, or $170 for a Friend of the Foundation ticket, which includes a $50 donation.
Come for the music. Stay for the connections. Leave knowing you've helped make a difference.
Learn more and register for NightOUT.
Giving Thanks for a Profession That Connects Us
As Thanksgiving approaches, the Pennsylvania Bar Association (PBA) is taking a moment to celebrate the people, partnerships and shared commitment to service that make Pennsylvania's legal community stronger.
The practice of law is about more than cases, clients and courtrooms. It's about relationships, lifelong learning, mentorship and making a difference in the communities we serve. The PBA is grateful for the attorneys, judges and legal professionals who dedicate their time and talents to advancing the profession and ensuring access to justice across the commonwealth.
This Thanksgiving, the PBA is grateful for the people who make the profession more than a profession — they make it a community.
The PBA, Pennsylvania Bar Foundation and Pennsylvania Bar Institute wish you a happy Thanksgiving and a great kick off to a wonderful holiday season.
Stay connected: pabar.org | pbi.org | pabarfoundation.org
Please note that the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and the Pennsylvania Bar Association (PBA) are separate organizations. For more information about PBA, visit pabar.org or follow on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
|
|
|
We Want To Hear From You...
We are always on the lookout for stories of interest relating to legal ethics, new issues in the practice of law, lawyer wellness, and funny or just plain weird stories about the legal profession. If you come across something you think might be enlightening, educational, or entertaining to our readers or social media followers, pass it along. If you are our original source, there may be a hat tip in it for you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|